THE POPE REPORT · THE SUNDAY DISAGREEMENTMike Pope · A Pope Studios Publication

THE POPE REPORT · THE SUNDAY DISAGREEMENT

OpinionBy Mike Pope5 minute read

Say What You Actually Think

Mike Pope on the cost of speaking plainly, what Illinois asks students to hear, and what adults owe people who disagree.

Mike Pope outdoors in a wooded area
Mike Pope · Original photograph

Mike Pope on the cost of speaking plainly, what Illinois asks students to hear, and what adults owe people who disagree.

Share this essay
FacebookLinkedInEmail

You can sit through an entire meeting where everybody says, “Sounds good,” and find out what they think on the way to their cars.

In the parking lot, they have questions. Some of those questions would have helped while the person making the decision was still in the room. The people asking them knew that. They also knew what asking might cost.

I spent years in public schools as a teacher and a principal. You learn there’s a sentence that gets you a nod and a sentence that gets you another meeting. After a while, you can hear both versions in your head before you open your mouth.

Everybody has a part they know how to play. At work, you might be the person who always says yes. At home, you might be the one who keeps the peace. Those parts can help you get through a day. They can also get you far into a life you chose because you were good at being the person it required. Take the promotion you’ve been working toward. Do you want the work that comes with it, or have you spent so long trying to get picked that you stopped asking?

My life has changed since I started saying more of what I actually think. Some people could look at those changes and say they wouldn’t call it an improvement. I would. I can tell somebody what I think, and I can tell them when I’m still figuring it out. I value that more than the comfort of knowing I said what the room expected.

Speaking honestly asks something of the person across from you. You tell them, “I think we made the wrong decision,” and give them a chance to hear you out. They may have given you very little reason to believe they can handle it. You’re still treating them like somebody capable of having the conversation.

I think that’s respect. Give people that respect before you know what they’ll do with it, and buckle up. Some people liked the arrangement where they could count on you to agree. The relationship can change when that arrangement changes. Other people might be relieved that someone finally said what they’d been thinking.

Part of speaking honestly is being clear about how certain you are. “I think we put too much weight on this one number” gives the other person something specific to answer. They can tell you why it mattered. You can find out they considered something you missed. “I hadn’t thought about that” belongs in an honest conversation, too.

That conversation gets hard to have when somebody starts answering a point you never made. You say, “We should spend a little less this month.” They hear, “We’re never allowed to have fun again.” Suddenly you’re defending a ban on fun while the bills are still sitting on the table.

That’s a straw man. Your position has been replaced with an easier one to attack. Sometimes the person misheard you. Give them a chance to tell you. Ask, “What did you hear me say?” Then wait. If they give you a different argument, put yours back on the table in one sentence. “I’m worried about what we’re spending this month. What concerns you about spending a little less?”

In a comment or an email, ask, “Can you quote the sentence you’re responding to?” Once you’re looking at the same words, you can talk about what each of you took from them. You might discover that your words gave someone an impression you hadn’t intended. You get a chance to clear that up.

Illinois starts teaching children how to do this in elementary school. Fourth-grade readers use details and examples to explain what a text says and what they infer from it. In fifth grade, students are asked to quote accurately to support both. They learn to show where their interpretation came from.

Both grades have language standards on nuances in word meaning. “I have questions about this” and “I’m against this” put different positions on the record. Change “some” to “all” and you can leave somebody defending a claim they would never have made.

The speaking and listening standards bring the same care to a conversation. Fourth-graders practice putting information they hear into their own words. Fifth-graders summarize a speaker’s points and explain what reasons and evidence support them. We expect children to demonstrate they understood the point before they move on to what they think of it.

I recently asked who had authority over the way a district’s parent committees were set up. The superintendent directed me to a principal who could talk about the committee at her school. I’m willing to have that conversation. My question about who designed the structure across schools and who can change it still needs its own answer.

There’s a sharper version of the question if you’re feeling impatient. “Can we do the fifth-grade part first? Tell me what you heard me ask.” That works on me, too. If I’ve got your point wrong, I want you to tell me while there’s still time to answer it.

Fifth-graders also look at accounts of the same event and notice how the people telling it see it differently. Someone across the table can have an honest account of the same meeting and remember a different moment than you do. They may have noticed a consequence you barely considered because they’re the one who’ll have to live with it.

I wish we gave each other more room for that in politics. Say you’re worried about a decision your own side made. If the first response is “So you’re with them now?” you learn pretty quickly what you can say around your own friends. When your side has the votes or sets the agenda, that’s when it takes some effort to hear people who see it differently. They might have a question you can’t answer. They might have a point you’ll have to take back to your own side.

People deserve to have their views heard and described fairly when a decision affects them. We can do that and still disagree about the decision. How can anybody represent a community if the only opinions they hear are the ones people think it’s safe to say?

Think of one conversation you’ve been replaying. There’s probably a sentence you wish you’d said. Say it in words you’d be willing to hear repeated back to you. If you’re still working through the thought, say that, too.

I’m trying to get better at saying it while the person who needs to hear it is still in the room. And when somebody takes that chance with me, I want them to get all the way through the sentence.

Mike PopeAuthor · Speaker · Creator of Pope Studios

Go deeper

BRING MIKE INTO THE CONVERSATION

Live interviews, moderated conversations, public Q&A, book conversations, and respectful disagreement.

Bring Mike In